ecoadvise & communication

        NEWS          EXPERIENCE           COUNTRIES            CLIENTS             PUBLICATIONS             PHOTOS              LINKS 

(Use Internet Explorer)

EcoAdvise & Communication Esthersvej 20A                     DK-2900 Hellerup        Denmark

See where it is           

Ph: +45 4011 3373 or             + 45 4090 4666  ecoadvise@ecoadvise.dk

Go to WWF Denmark website with Greenland reports: Click on the image above.

HOME

EcoAdvise & Communication

 

THE WALRUS IN GREENLAND

Last update 26.9.2006 23.00 UTC

 

 

 

 

EU bans import of walrus from Greenland

26.9.2006

 

EU wildlife experts has today decided to ban import to EU of walrus parts and products originating in Greenland. The Scientific Review Group (SRG) for CITES did not find current management of walrus in Greenland sustainable. Not even the newly imposed hunting quota for the rest of 2006 could convince the EU experts.

 

The ban only covers commercial imports, however the numbers are insignificant. As an example the commercial import to Denmark from Greenland has dropped from 281 items in 2004 to zero in 2006.

 

At the same time import of personal items made of walrus has increased from a few hundred more than 1,000 in a few years. This trade, that includes tourist souvenirs, will not be affected by the new EU import ban.

 

Greenland announce first walrus hunting quota: 60 in three months 

20.9.2006

 

Today, just six days before EU experts will decide on a proposed importban of walrus, Greenland announced a walrus hunting quota.

 

The decision is coming up after the scientific authority of CITES in the U.K. was not able to declare the Greenlandic walrus management for sustainable. 

 

From 1st October to 31st December this year, 60 walrus may be hunted in West Greenland. Walrus' lost during hunting shall also be counted by the hunters. No information is given on a 2007 quota.

 

 

Greenlands own biologist recommend a total catch including losses should not be more than 50 walrus annually.

Greenland Homerule press release (in Danish)

Greenland Homerule press release (in English)

Importban of walrus to EU expected 

7.9.2006

 

Following a recent application for commercial import of walrus to Denmark the British CITES Scientific Authority has issued a negative opinion. Following this, EU Scientific Review Group is expected to recommend a ban on import of walrus products to EU. The ban will only cover commercial transactions and not e.g. tourist souvenirs. Thus, the ban will be almost ineffective since a wast part of all CITES exports from Greenland is made by tourists and therefor regarded as personal (P) transactions.

A previous study of narwhal exports made by EcoAdvise showed that 95-98% of all Greenlandic CITES export permits covered personal transactions.

 

An EU decision on walrus import from Greenland is expected 26th September, 2006.

 

 

Photo: Danish Minister of Foreign Affairs Per Stig Møller with a walrus skull. The skull was a gift from a Greenlandic mayor and  Prime Minister Hans Enoksen (left). The skull was later confiscated since it was imported to Denmark without the necessary CITES permits. 

 

Greenland revise walrus protection

6.7.2006

 

The Greenlandic Homerule government has decided on a new walrus protection legislation and a hunting quota will be set. The quota will be published in August 2006 according to the Homerule. 

 

Link to homerule docs on walrus legislation (in English)

 

 

Abstracts from the WWF Denmark report "The Big Four" (april 2005):

 

Walrus in Greenland

 

Greenland hosts three populations of walrus:

 

1)   The North Water population: All year in the polynia of the Baffin Bay and Smith Sound. These walruses are absent from coastal areas during the open water season in August-September. At this time the population summers in Canada along Ellesmere Island.

It is estimated (2005), that this population consists of about 1,500 animals (www.natur.gl).

2)   The West Greenland population: Occurs from fall to spring at the edge of the Baffin Bay pack ice, between 66°30’N and 70°30’N, that is from somewhere south of Sisimiut to the Disco Island in the north. In addition a few animals are assumed to spend the winter in open water areas around Uummannaq and Upernavik. It is estimated (2005), that this population consists of about 1,000 animals.

3)   The East Greenland population: Resident in the shallow waters along the east coast and is mainly confined to the National Park (see map page 6). It is assumed that interaction with other populations is only very limited. It is estimated (2005), that this population consists of about 1,000 animals.

 

 

Table: The Atlantic walrus populations [3]

 

Populations

1)      Foxe Basin (CA)

2)      Southern and Eastern Hudson Bay   (CA)

3)      Northern Hudson Bay to SE Baffin Island (CA and GL?)

4)      West Greenland (GL)

5)      North Water (GL and CA)

6)      East Greenland (GL)

7)      Svalbard and Franz Josephs Land (NO and RU)

8)      Kara Sea to  Novaya Zemlaya (RU)

Estimate and certainty

5,500 (2,700-11,200 95% CI)

 

Unknown

 

Unknown

1,000 (estimate[4])

1,500 (estimate)

1,000 (estimate)

 

2,000

 

Unknown

Trend

Stable?

 

Unknown

 

Unknown

Declining

Declining

Stable/increasing

 

Increasing

 

Increasing

 

Genetic studies and information on migration supports the view that the three Greenlandic walrus populations represent separate units and should be managed accordingly [5].

 

Table 7: International conservation efforts

 

Red list category (IUCN):

Not listed. Only the walrus populations named as the Laptev walrus in Russia is listed: Data Deficient (1994)

 

CITES:

Walrus has been listed on CITES Appendix III by Canada in 1975. In 1987 CITES concluded that the international trade level did not warrant an increased level of protection [6].

 

EU wildlife trade regulations:

Annex B.

 

NAMMCO:

This is a regional multi-lateral agreement, which focuses on the management of marine mammals in the North Atlantic, the member states Greenland, the Faeroe Islands, Norway and Iceland. NAMMCO has issued research and management recommendations for the walrus, e.g.:

In 1995 the Management Committee recommended that Greenland take appropriate steps to arrest the decline of the walrus along its west coast, and encouraged Canada toconsider working co-operatively with Greenland, to assist in achieving this objective.

In 2004 a workshop on walrus hunting methods was held in Copenhagen.

 

Historically the walrus was much more abundant in Greenland. In a new study [7], abundance estimates for a period approximately 100 years ago, are calculated by extrapolating historical hunting statistics and recent abundance estimates. The study suggests the following historical pre-harvest populations:

 

 

The North Water:           About 15,000 animals in year 1900 (CI 90%: 7,800-22,300)

West Greenland:             About 16,000 animals in year 1900 (CI 90%: 10,500-21,500)

East Greenland:              About 1,600 animals in year 1889 (CI 90%: 941-2,860)

 

 

Although, the data is uncertain, it indicates much higher walrus abundance in western and north-western Greenland for the period roughly 100 years ago. The current populations are fragments of such previously abundant populations. Historical and current hunting is the main cause for this decline.

  

Opposite, the eastern Greenland population is today very close to its pre-harvest abundance probably, due to the absence of hunters in eastern Greenland since the mid-20th century. In 1956 the walrus was also declared totally protected north of Ittoqqortoormiit.  Today the hunt in eastern Greenland is limited and is assumed to be well below sustainable harvest levels.

 

This trend is also reflected by the walrus’ retreat further and further north along the western Greenlandic coast over the last century. Today the walrus has left all haul-out sites on the west coast and only come ashore in north eastern Greenland, in the remote and un-inhabited National Park (see Figure below).


Greenland has not yet published an official Red list using the IUCN criteria for identifying species in need of conservation.

 

The Greenlandic Institute for Natural Resources has, in 2000, instead published a report “Status 2000”, listing “the important living resources”.  In the status report the walrus, along with the polar bear, is classified as an:

 

Important species with possible problems (due to hunting or other), and were current scientific knowledge to some extend is lacking but sufficient for management initiatives in Greenland

 

  

 

 

Figure 1: Historical and current walrus haul-out sites in Greenland. Since the early part of the 20th century, walruses have, due to human disturbance, abandoned all of the west coast (crosses). They are now found only at two sites in the National Park (dots) (From: Hansen 2002. Used with permission).

 

 

 

 

Figure 2: Historical and current walrus population trends in Greenlandic according to Erik Born in the books "Walrus in Greenland" published by Ilinniusiorfik in 2005. Top: North West Greenlandic population. Middle: North Water population. Bottom: East Greenlandic population.



[1] Witting & Born 2005

[2] www.natur.gl

[3] NAMMCO 95

[4] Witting & Born 2005

[5] NAMMCO 1995

[6] Hall 2003

[7] See also Born (2005b)

Full references will be added soon

 Photo by WWF/Canon - from the report "The Big Four".